| Rank | Episode | Avg. Score | Votes Counted |
| 1 | Proof of the Pudding | 4.71 | 258 |
| 2 | The Journey Begins | 4.48 | 260 |
| 3 | Malcolm and the Baby | 4.33 | 150 |
| 4 | The Witch of Avonlea | 4.25 | 158 |
| 5 | The Story Girl Earns Her Name | 4.23 | 217 |
| 6 | The Quarantine at Abraham's | 4.2 | 215 |
| 7 | Aunt Abigail's Beau | 4.17 | 160 |
| 8 | Felicity's Challenge | 4.06 | 163 |
| 9 | Nothing Endures But Change | 3.97 | 158 |
| 10 | Hope Chest of Arabella King | 3.94 | 151 |
| 11 | Materializing of Duncan | 3.88 | 195 |
| 12 | Conversions | 3.63 | 161 |
| 13 | Old Lady Lloyd | 3.32 | 184 |