| Rank | Episode | Avg. Score | Votes Counted |
| 1 | Love May Be Blind... | 4.56 | 124 |
| 2 | So Dear to My Heart | 4.56 | 159 |
| 3 | Secrets and Sacrifices | 4.41 | 86 |
| 4 | Out of the Ashes | 4.4 | 104 |
| 5 | Return to Me | 4.32 | 131 |
| 6 | Woman of Importance | 4.24 | 109 |
| 7 | The Last Hurrah | 3.77 | 81 |
| 8 | After the Ball is Over | 3.61 | 75 |
| 9 | Ah... Sweet Mystery of Life | 3.46 | 78 |
| 10 | Total Eclipse | 3.23 | 77 |
| 11 | King of the Great White Way | 2.59 | 79 |
| 12 | Davey and the Mermaid | 2.02 | 85 |
| 13 | From Away | 1.88 | 81 |